PROP conflict of interest in Phoenix House rehabs

Doctor: Overprescribing contributing to opiate epidemic – News – – Hyannis, MA

Here are the radical and unscientific views of the president of PROP, which dovetail with his business interest: the corrupt and government-financed rahab/recovery industry.

Dr. Andrew Kolodny would not win a popularity contest with many others in the medical field. “I cross lines, in my interactions with my colleagues,” he said.

It’s disturbing when the leader of a the campaign against giving pain patients relief shows pride in his inability to get along with others.  

Kolodny, executive director of PROP, Physicians for Responsible Opioid Prescribing, presented his take on the opioid epidemic at the Cape Cod Symposium on Addictive Disorders held in Hyannis on Friday night.

Kolodny, a psychiatrist and medical director of the Phoenix House, said the medical community was duped by aggressive and misleading marketing about the safety of opioids starting in 1996 by the pharmaceutical industry. This led to rampant overprescribing of oxycodone and hydrocodone.

These two chemical alterations of opium are so similar to heroin they should be called “heroin pills,” Kolodny said.

This is the ultimate in derogatory and shaming language. Kolodny goes even further than calling these medicines narcotics by directly linking our pain medication to heroin, he shows his prejudice and extremism.

The popular notion that heroin overdoses are up because doctors no longer overprescribe opiate-based pain pills is false, Kolodny said. Heroin overdose deaths have gone up since 2010 because of the increased use of fentanyl, a powerful narcotic that dealers add to or sell as heroin, he said.

But doctors are still overprescribing pills, he said.

“It’s really striking how white this epidemic is,” Kolodny said. These are clues, Kolodny said, that doctors still fail to appreciate the danger of the opioids. He said the racial bias doctors and dentists hold against black or Latino people has been a healthy protector for those populations; physicians are reluctant to prescribe narcotics to them.

He posed the question: How could highly trained and intelligent doctors be fooled into thinking opioid drugs are not addictive?

Purdue Pharma called doctor’s opioid fears, “barriers to compassionate pain care,” Kolodny said. “Their message was so compelling: we’re letting our patients suffer needlessly.”

The message still gets clouded by pitting the chronic pain patients against addicts, Kolodny said.

Kolodny maintains these groups are highly connected and both are being harmed by opiates.

Here again, Kolodny shows extreme prejudice by focusing only on the fact that addicts seek out and abuse the same medicine as pain patients need to live decent lives.

Opioids ruin an addict’s life, while they enhance a pain patient’s life.

He said there is little evidence opiates can be safely prescribed for chronic pain. “But there’s a lot of evidence it’s really dangerous,” Kolodny said.

This is blatantly false. There is the fact that opioids are used to successfully manage pain for patients, among whom only 3-5% become addicted. Such odds are typical for the cost./benefit ratios of many drugs with severe side effects, like statins.

A 2009 study by the Jefferson College of Population Health of Thomas Jefferson University looked at 938,420 urine samples of chronic pain patients on opioids. Researchers found that 11 percent had illicit drugs in their urine, 30 percent had medicine not prescribed to them, and 38 percent had no opiates at all in their system, indicating they were selling their prescriptions, Kolodny said

No, it has been shown that this is actually because the tests used in the office aren’t very accurate and may not be able to detect certain opioid metabolites.

Kolodny’s criticism of his colleagues has not been easy. He had worked as chairman of psychiatry at Maimonides Medical Center in Brooklyn, New York, a dream job, according to many of his friends and colleagues, he said. He gave it up in order to devote more time to PROP. He has since become medical director at the treatment organization Phoenix House.

Maybe he gave us his regular job because it wasn’t as public and didn’t give him the recognition he craves. Maybe he gave it up because he wasn’t good at it or didn’t enjoy it.

Perhaps he was not respected among his medical colleagues due to his unscientific statements, prejudiced approach, callous disregard for evidence, and closed mind. 

Maybe Kolodny gave up his position in a medical program because he does not adhere to scientific principles and is thus far more suited to the unregulated, propaganda fueled, media-hyped recovery industry, which is not based on scientific principles.

The treatment organization he has taken a part in is notoriously ineffective and corrupt, fails to hold its recovery houses up to standards, and repeatedly fails audits.

I will detail the abuses of Kolodny’s recovery business in my next post.

23 thoughts on “PROP conflict of interest in Phoenix House rehabs

  1. Vicki

    I take pain medication so I can be a part of life, not detached from life. I would be bedridden without them. If there was a cure for my illness I would throw my pills away in a heartbeat.

    Liked by 2 people

    1. Zyp Czyk Post author

      Me too – I hate having to take my pills! There are many pain patients that feel this way and we’re clearly very different from addicts.

      Kolodny really believes everyone taking opioids is the same and he may be convincing other doctors to believe that BS too. If we could find some way of proving a difference between us and addicts, we could solve this problem, but I don’t think there’s a “measurable” physiological difference to be found :-(

      Liked by 1 person

      1. AddictionMyth

        I don’t think doctors want to believe it but sometimes it’s just easier to go along. Patients are part of the problem. I know a smart lady who was in pain but was indignant when the doctor prescribed percocet, as if it were poison. She asked for a substitute so he prescribed Norco. Which was fine with her. LOL patients are pretty stupid too.

        Liked by 1 person

  2. Pingback: Outrageous Conflict of Interest in the Debate Over Opioids | EDS Info (Ehlers-Danlos Syndrome)

  3. Pingback: » Kolodny: “Anyone taking opioids regularly is addicted.” PHARMACIST STEVE

  4. Pingback: Kolodny: “Anyone taking opioids regularly is addicted.” | Pained Lives Matter

  5. Pingback: Anti-Opioid Propaganda and Profit | EDS Info (Ehlers-Danlos Syndrome)

  6. Emily Raven

    I love how he quotes marketing that happened in 96…. I haven’t seen any opiates advertised my whole teen/adult life (just psych meds) so I’m snarkily wondering what this has to do with the tramadol i’ve only been on for 6 years.

    Also Kolodny was an ADDICT. HEROIN ADDICT. NEVER IN PAIN. The fact that we take any form of narcotic makes us less credible so no wonder he does the ego/look how new and different my ideas are show… anyone who were to really sit down and think about it would find it completely stupid hes making decisions for people with real medical issues not an addiction.

    Liked by 1 person

  7. Charlie Payne

    “Kolodny, a psychiatrist and medical director of the Phoenix House, said the medical community was duped by aggressive and misleading marketing about the safety of opioids starting in 1996 by the pharmaceutical industry. This led to rampant overprescribing of oxycodone and hydrocodone.” What a lying piece of garbage! First of all, if a doctor who is over the age of 10 years old didn’t know that opiates weren’t addictive then they shouldn’t have a license! 2. I want to meet this Kolodny and watch him live through 40, yes 40 years of cluster headaches, Torn muscles and ligaments in my chest and ankle. Arthritis, pretty much everywhere as well as diverticulitis! Watch all the pain I have in his face and kick him out of the office and tell him he is seeking drugs! Put a major note in his file that he is an addict with drug seeking behavior and since he a clean UA also put in his file that he sells his pills! Yeah but the bottle says as needed for pain? Sorry if you don’t take all the pain pills everyday, ensuring a bigger chance of addiction, your selling them! Do nothing, give him the bill and tell him to get some aspirin. Oh wait stop Mr. Kolodny, would you like a referral for addiction treatment?

    Liked by 1 person

    1. Zyp Czyk Post author

      Yes, let’s invite him to join us in our world of pain without relief.

      He’s living in a fantasy world and seeing addiction everywhere, so he needs to experience our misery and hopeless prognosis.


  8. Loura Shares A Story

    Hello! I am new to your blog, but wanted to alert you to an open letter I just wrote today about Dr. Kolodny. My research was partly informed by several articles on your blog here, so I wanted to thank you and share the results:

    Please feel free to comment, contact me, and/or share. I’m hoping there are enough “hints” for our political leaders to take in this!


    Loura :)

    Liked by 1 person

    1. Zyp Czyk Post author

      Excellent! I’m always very happy to hear that someone was able to make such good use of information I’ve posted here because that was my goal for this blog. I try to be very conscientious, accurate, and factual with all I’m writing, but I have to admit I’m highly biased abut what articles I select. I figure there are enough people pushing the anti-opioid agenda already.

      I’ll have time to check your post out more closely later today and may refer to it on EDSinfo as well.

      Liked by 1 person


Other thoughts?

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.