Opioids vs. NSAIDs for Chronic Pain — Pain News Network– May 11, 2017 – By Roger Chriss, Columnist
…Minneapolis Star Tribune reporting on a new study that found “patients with chronic pain fared no better with the potentially addictive painkillers than they did with non-opioid meds.”
“If pain doctors still think these medicines are effective, then they have a lot of explaining to do and their competence and professionalism deserve to be challenged,” said Chris Johnson, MD, who is a board member of PROP as well as the Steve Rummler Hope Foundation.
But the study did not show that opioids were ineffective, only that non-opioids were more effective in this particular study.
Thus, pain doctors are justified in claiming they are effective. Of course, so are NSAIDs, but this is not a new or surprise finding. Similar results have been obtained before, though only in shorter-term studies.
But a response like the one from Dr. Johnson is another example of over-generalization and simplification of a complex medical result, and how anti-opioid activists often spin research findings to fit their agendas
It also insults the expertise of physicians like Roger Chou, MD, a Professor at Oregon Health & Science University’s School of Medicine and one of the lead authors of the CDC guidelines; and Sean Mackey, MD, Chief of the Division of Pain Medicine at Stanford University and immediate past president of the American Academy of Pain Medicine.
The research was conducted by Erin Krebs, MD, who is investigating the efficacy of medications for osteoarthritis aspart of a study called the Strategies for Prescribing Analgesics Comparative Effectiveness (SPACE).
(Editor’s note: Dr. Krebs appeared in a lecture series on opioid prescribing that was funded by the Steve Rummler Hope Foundation, which is the fiscal sponsor of Physicians for Responsible Opioid Prescribing (PROP), an anti-opioid activist group.)
In a recent Medscape interview, Dr. Chou said, “I don’t think there’s anything inherently wrong with maintaining somebody on low doses of opioids, as long as it’s doing what it’s supposed to in terms of helping their pain and function and not causing harm.”
And in a recent Vox interview, Dr. Mackey said, “The fact is if you go looking, there’s clearly data out there that opioids improve pain. These drugs would have never been approved by the FDA if they didn’t.”
“Everything we know about pain is that this is a complex biopsychosocial phenomenon,” said Dr. Chou.
Or as Forest Tennant, MD, put it in Practical Pain Management: “A major point to be made about painful genetic diseases is that pain will almost always worsen as the patient ages.”
A summary of the SPACE research states that the “findings showed no significant advantage of opioid therapy compared with non-opioid medication therapy.”
Chronic Pain is a Complex Problem
Chronic pain management is thus a long-term endeavor requiring as many tools as possible. What works for one person may be ineffective or even contraindicated in another person.
A major study released this week also found that NSAIDs increase the risk of a heart attack.
The converse also holds. Some people do not tolerate opioids well, have too much brain fog or get constipated.
Thus, the “risk profile” of each person must be considered. No medication is perfectly safe. According to the FDA, as many as 20,000 people die from NSAID use every year.
The unfortunate reality is that pain management is often a lifelong necessity for people who suffer from chronic pain disorders.
Such people don’t have the luxury of ideological debates or moralistic disputes. They need a pain toolkit that is as well-equipped as possible, and they have to deal with medication trade-offs in order to address their medical problems.
Prescribing decisions are best left to experienced physicians who know their patients and the medical conditions they have, and can work with them on the risks and benefits of opioids and NSAIDs.