Study Shows Surgery Reduces Chronic Opioid Use

Surprising Finding: Study Shows Surgery Reduces Chronic Opioid Use – Pain Medicine Newsby Michael Vlessides – May 2020

Among chronic opioid users, having surgery seems to be associated with a faster time to opioid discontinuationcontrary to popular belief.

I’m very curious about what they consider “contrary to popular belief”. It doesn’t make much sense to believe that having surgery leads to a “longer time to opioid discontinuation.”

“Of patients coming to our operating rooms, 23% will already be on an opioid by the time they see you on the day of surgery, and 3% will be chronic opioid users,” said Naheed Jivraj, MD.  

Though few articles mention it, opioids are deployed to combat pain, and having pain is precisely why these folks need surgery.

“Second, it’s unclear whether there are any risk factors associated with prolonged or continued opioid use in this population.”

Of note, the study found that a greater proportion of patients discontinued opioids in the year after surgery than their counterparts who did not have surgery (36% vs. 29%; P≤0.001).

I’m astonished that there’s only a 7% difference. If pain is resolved by surgery opioids would no longer be necessary, but we’ve learned that surgery can serve to aggravate a pain problem or incite another one instead of solving it.

The Pendulum Has Swung

Yet as Gregory Hare, MD, PhD, a professor of anesthesia at the University of Toronto, was quick to point out, discontinuing opioids may not necessarily be the holy grail that many clinicians think.

I congratulate Dr. Hare for his wisdom and ability to see through the smokescreen of the CDC’s guidelines, which have been interpreted to mean basically that opioids are dangerous and must be reduced or even stopped, even if they are effective and causing no problems for the patient.

“Is discontinuation of chronic opioids a good thing or a bad thing?” asked Dr. Hare, who was not involved in the study. “You may have people who are taking a Tylenol 3 [codeine-acetaminophen, Janssen] and they’re shopping, doing activities and seeing their friends, and I don’t think that’s a problem.’

“So I think these are important data, but it’s important to know who’s being harmed by being a chronic opioid user and who’s actually being helped, because I think the pendulum has swung way too far to one side,” Dr. Hare said.

This is exactly the issue: opioids themselves aren’t bad or good, but how people use them can be.

“I agree with you in terms of the pendulum being swung too far in the other direction,” Dr. Jivraj replied. “We’re seeing that already. For example, we’ve seen that chronic opioid users whose medications have been discontinued will subsequently go to other sources, whether it’s on the street or otherwise, and it’s caused an increase in opioid-related mortality.

And here Dr. Jivraj is spouting the usual anti-opioid PROPaganda because he’s only thinking of addiction treatment, not pain treatment.

Repeatedly and without questioning their extreme bias, the media has supported PROP in associating all opioids with addiction and views the issue of chronic pain as mainly a psychological problem if it acknowledges pain at all.

1 thought on “Study Shows Surgery Reduces Chronic Opioid Use

  1. Charles Bruscino

    Medical errors are the third leading cause of death in this country and cause untold permanent disabilities and chronic pain. (It’s worse than the overdose epidemic.) No one has estimated how many people have been affected by the latter. I’m one of these unfortunate “victims” of medical errors. Surgery crippled me and the offending doctor is still in denial 25 years later.

    Surgeries are invasive and traumatic. There are no guarantees any surgery will be successful and NOT cause further complications, injuries, or death. This is precisely why patients have to sign consent papers before surgery. Poor or nonexistent post-op care can also maim and kill.

    Doctors are not Gods. Never have been. They are however highly trained human beings with all attendant faults, weaknesses, pressures and biases. With the advent of the Internet, any doctor’s work/diagnoses/recommendations can be checked instantaneously. I recommend nih.gov, National Institute of Health, as a starting point to check your doctor’s work. Other reputable medical information sites are also available. Stay away from web sites not created by actual doctors or medical centers. As a consumer of medical services you are entitled to know as much about your doctor’s work and your conditions as possible. Be a savvy consumer, get 2nd and 3rd opinions if you can. Do your homework and check reputable online medical resources. Don’t become a statistic after surgery.

    Liked by 2 people

    Reply

Other thoughts?

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.