Comment on Opioid Limits to HHS Task Force

This was published in the National Pain Report as What I Told the U.S. Government About Pain, but in case you didn’t see it, here it is:

I just have so much to say about this governmental intrusion into our medical care that I couldn’t figure out what to write. So, I decided to comment on just one facet of this ridiculous “war on opioids”: standardizing opioid milligrams prescribed for pain.

I believe we can leave numerous comments, starting with a fresh form each time so I may write another. Just to give you ideas, here’s the comment I left:

I’m writing to urge that you please don’t let the government set standard opioid dose limits for individual patients. Opioids are my only means of relief from a painful connective tissue disorder.  

Pain is, by biological design, the most forceful and unpleasant sensation a human body can experience. As a primal alarm of danger and impending death, it demands immediate attention and action. Pain is the most powerful persuader and has been used throughout human history to force people to act against their will by torture.

And when this powerful sensation becomes relentlessly constant, when there’s no escape from this pain, no hope for its easing, no end to its presence, life can become too painful to live. (as evidenced by the increasing numbers of suicides by pain patients cut off from their pain relief)

I inherited a permanently painful disabling disorder, Ehlers-Danlos Syndrome, and have been taking high doses of opioids for over 20 years. Countless other treatments, therapies, and medications were ineffective or far too expensive. For me and many others, only opioids provide effective pain relief.

Here is a list of non-opioid therapies, like those you recommend, which I’ve tried and found ineffective:

  • interventional procedures: nerve blocks, epidurals, and even surgery
  • biofeedback
  • physical therapy
  • massage
  • chiropractic
  • acupuncture
  • drugs used for Fibromyalgia: Lyrica, Neurontin, Cymbalta, Savella, Soma, Flexeril
  • psychiatric medications: antidepressants, antiepileptics, mood stabilizers, even antipsychotics
  • Stanford Pain Management Program
  • psychotherapy, including an addiction counselor who determined that I am not an addict, just a person in pain

Enforcing arbitrary opioid dose limits condemns many of us to live the rest of our lives tormented by our pain, which certainly constitutes a “cruel and unusual punishment” for pain patients.

The CDC Guideline was never intended to set specific dosage limits, yet it’s being used to legislate absolute rules for what should be individualized medical decisions. It is biased, based on admittedly manipulated data (overdoses were counted multiple times if multiple drugs were found), overlooks essential facts about opioid prescribing, and makes strong recommendations based on weak evidence.

Standard medication dosages imposed by government are inappropriate for medical practice.

Setting a standard dose for pain medication is like setting a standard time for cooking a roast without knowing the amount or type of meat (amount or type of pain) or the temperature of the oven (opioid metabolism of the patient).

People have very different kinds of pain and different genetic profiles that cause them to metabolize opioids differently, so effective doses can vary by a factor of 100.

Worst of all, this effectively condemns many of our veterans to a lifetime of pain: those who fought for this country, were gravely wounded, and have permanent injuries that leave them with intractable pain. How can we force them to suffer like this?

Opioid medications are not as dangerous as rumored and do not “cause addiction”. If these medications were addictive as some claim, the millions of people who take a few opioid tablets after surgery would be addicted. This is clearly not the case.

Opioids have been used effectively against pain for thousands of years, and are addictive for only a small subset of humanity, less than 5%. We cannot protect these people from addiction by forcing so many other people with chronic pain, conservatively estimated at 25 million, to live with incapacitating pain.

Limits intended for one problematic population (recreational/addicted users) will strongly and exclusively impact a different and innocent population (patients with permanent pain).  Overdoses are mostly from multiple drugs and illicit opioids, not from opioids prescribed to the individual and taken as directed.

The “crisis” is one of addiction, not a particular drug, and the results after 3 years of imposing dose limits: opioid prescribing way down, overdoses way up.

When our pain relieving medication is drastically decreased (and in some cases stopped without notice or aftercare), we can no longer function in our jobs or family roles, we become dependent and burdensome to our loved ones, and our lives become a progression of daily suffering.  

Please don’t deprive me and so many other citizens of pain relief based on an arbitrary opioid dosage standardized for the mythical “average” American.

It’s not my fault that I need opioids because I inherited a painful condition.

It’s not my fault that some people using illicit opioids are overdosing.

Why must I suffer for the self-destructive behavior of others?

The deadline for comments is April 1 – April Fools’ Day – an appropriate coincidence.

Here’s the direct link to the comment input:

Docket HHS-OS-2018-0027-0001

The Department of Health and Human Services (HHS)
Notice: Request for Public Comments on the Pain Management Best Practices Inter-Agency Task Force Draft Report on Pain Management Best Practices: Updates, Gaps, Inconsistencies, and Recommendations


2 thoughts on “Comment on Opioid Limits to HHS Task Force

  1. peter jasz

    (RE: Fed’s, HHS “Taskfarce”, Tapering etc.)

    All of this a Circus ‘Side-Show’: It’s ALL known. the devastation, ruined-lives, pain/suffering -Everything. More than ever, In today’s computer day/age, algorithms tell us a great deal.
    And the government knows this/uses this data -right down to ‘voter’ impact. By ‘region’ no less.

    These are Crimes Against Humanity, Cold-blooded murder (second-degree, manslaughter, Malfeasance -causing death/suicide) is what all of those involved shall face -and answer to.

    All of this repeated talk is nothing other than semantics; its gone on/wasted time/lives, far too long. Some real “teeth” are required to unravel the government personnel responsible for such atrocious indifference to the human condition -and the suffering they ARE responsible for.

    No “War” big enough to warrant the time/money invested? Start one at home ! (But to pick a war against an opponent -vicious pain sufferer’s- so devastatingly injured ????). Class act alright.

    The unraveling of society will NOT come from some “outside” source, but rather from within.

    peter jasz

    Liked by 1 person


Other thoughts?

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.